I Etcetera: On the Poetics and Ideology of Multipersoned Narratives

Brian Richardson

Style · 1994 · 32 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

you have to say, It's who am doing this to me, who am talking about me to me. Then breath fails, end begins, you go silent, it's end, short-lived, you begin again, you had forgotten, there's someone there, someone talking to you, about you, about him ... all have to do is listen, then they depart, one by one, and voice goes on, it's not theirs, they were never there, there was never anyone but you, talking to you about you, breath fails (Beckett, The Unnamable 394) One of most significant omissions in contemporary narrative theory is absence of sustained accounts of multiple narration. For most part, narrative theory generally proceeds as if all novels were written entirely in first person or third person, heterodiegetic or homodiegetic. One understands desire for unambiguous foundations and paradigmatic examples, and naturally all theorists go on to identify more complex and ambiguous strategies of narration, but this situation leads to a conceptual framework in which univocal practice is set forth as a (perhaps unintentional) norm while more heterodox experiments are consequently treated as secondary, peripheral, or even perverse literary gamesmanship. In this way, models of narrative ultimately derived from linguistics take precedence over Bakhtinian claims of fundamentally polymorphous nature of novel. Thus, while many typologies contain a space for both Bloom's subvocal speech and Molly's internal monologue, there is usually no place in such schemas for Ulysses as a whole as if conjunction of different narrators and modes of narration were not itself of primary theoretical importance.(1) This gap is all more unfortunate when one considers a work like The Sound and Fury, in which first-person memory monologues, as Dorrit Cohn calls them (247-55), are starkly juxtaposed to resolutely third-person segment that concludes novel. In what follows will examine a number of different texts that employ multipersoned narration. Four major kinds of multipersoned texts may be identified at outset: works that systematically oscillate between different narrative positions, those that collapse apparently different types of narration into a single voice, works whose narration remains fundamentally ambiguous, and texts that employ narrational stances that would be impossible in nonfictional discourse. Since many of authors and critics of works will be discussing frequently invoke ideological reasons to explain their chosen narrative practice, a short excursus on politics of narrative person will also be set forth. Throughout, will pay particular attention to texts which employ second-person narration. It is no exaggeration to state that emergence of second-person narration is precisely what makes speculation on multipersoned fiction inevitable. In a frequently quoted aside, Wayne Booth remarked in 1961 that perhaps most overworked distinction in theory of fiction is that of person (150). believe we will find instead that person remains one of most undertheorized distinctions in field. Alternating narration between different grammatical persons is not an exclusively modern phenomenon. As Stanzel has pointed out, Thackeray's narrator employs both I and he to describe his life in Henry Esmond. In Bleak House, an omniscient third-person narrative is juxtaposed to first-person account of one of characters. Stanzel explains that narrative situations represent two different perspectives, namely, panoramic one of authorial narrator who is critical of times and naive but sympathetic viewpoint of first-person narrator, Esther Summerson, circumscribed by her domestic horizons (71). Even in this description, it might be noted, we get a sense of ideological valences present in such a gendered division of knowledge and narration. As Susan Sniader Lanser points out, by replicating ideology of separate spheres, Bleak House sets the omniscient and implicitly male voice of authorial narrator next to personal voice of female character Esther Summerson without acknowledging this duality (239-40). …