Comparing Variability of Two Measurement Processes Using R&R Studies

Richard K. Burdick, A. Elizabeth Allen, Greg A. Larsen

Journal of Quality Technology · 2002 · 24 citations · 10 references

Concepts

Abstract

In this paper we consider two methods for comparing variability of two measurement processes. The comparisons are based on statistics commonly computed in an R&R study. Computer simulation is used to compare methods and to support our recommendations. The basic conclusions are that: i) a simple method proposed by Cochran (1951) works well across a wide variety of conditions typically encountered in R&R studies, and is recommended over a modified large sample method; and ii) in studies where operators are randomly selected, samples of more than three operators are needed to provide useful results.

References

10