1978 · 48 citations · 0 references
Public AffairsPublic AdministrationPublic PolicyPublic EconomicsPublic HistoryPublic Sector ReformGovernment GrowthPublic Policy HistoryGovernment Expansion
INTRODUCTIONnn n From the early 1940s to the mid-1970s the range of governmentnactivities and the size of the public services in Australia havenconsistently increased. In the first two years of the Whitlamngovernment the growth in the size of the federal public servicenaccelerated dramatically, but economic problems in 1975 and thenadvent of the Eraser government brought this to a halt. The suddennhalt was not caused solely by a change of ministry: it also indicatedna change of mood created by a long debate on the proper andnpracticable roles of government in social and economic life. Evennbefore the change from Whitlam to Eraser, there had beennwidespread questioning of the functions, responsibilities andneffectiveness of the federal and state public services in Australia.n n The establishment of a wave of public service inquiries withinnthe last five years was one significant symbol of this broadnquestioning. These inquiries included the Bland board of inquirynin Victoria (1973-75), the Corbett committee in South Australian(1973-75), a ministerial inquiry into machinery of government innNew South Wales (1974) and, at the federal level, the RoyalnCommission on Australian Government Administration (RCAGA)nchaired by Dr H.C. Coombs (1974-76).' On taking office, thenEraser government set up the Administrative Review Committeenchaired by Sir Henry Bland. In New South Wales the Wran Laborngovernment appointed Professor Peter Wilenski early in 1977 toninquire into state government administration yet again.n n Public service inquiries have a long history in Australia, but thenmost recent group came after a noticeable gap. The RoyalnCommission on Australian Government Administration was the firstnwide-ranging inquiry into the federal public service since thenMcLachlan commission in 1919^ and the economies commissionnin 1919-20.' In the intervening period there were two otherncommittees of inquirymthe Bailey committee in 1944q and thenBoyer committee in 1958^mbut their terms of reference werenlimited to personnel policy. The situation was similar in the states.nThe recent Australian inquiries followed a number of prominentninquiries in comparable countriesmMcCarthy in New Zealand,nGlassco in Canada, Devlin in Eire, Fulton in the United Kingdomnand Cronyn in Ontario. In all of these cases, whatever the actionntaken by governments, the reports themselves have provoked annextensive literature and provided information and cognitive mapsnfor others wishing to explore the services they examined. At thenvery least they have become convenient mile postsmpeople refer,nfor example, to the post-Glassco and post-Fulton periods.n n The essays in this volume examine the three state inquiriesncompletedmin South Australia and Victoria, and the ministerialnreview in New South Walesmand RCAGA. Our interests are twofold.nFirst, we are concerned with examining the reports themselves. Thenessays present a set of textual reviews which put the recommendationsnof the reports in the context of broader debates about thentopics they discuss. Second, we are interested in the mechanics ofnthe inquiriesmthat is, how they were set up, run and implemented.nThus the chapters on the state inquiries and eight of the chaptersnon RCAGA are concerned with the contents of the reports themselves.nThe state chapters also discuss the background to the reports. Thenchapters by Hawker and Schaffer view the activities of RCAGA fromnthe inside, focusing on operational problems and the chapters bynMatthews and Chapman examine problems of implementation,ngenerally in the latter case and with specific reference to RCAGA innthe former.n n We cannot claim our coverage is exhaustive. In particular, sincenmost of the reports were only published within the last two or threenyears, it is still too early to judge their final effects. Even thoughngovernments may praise reports loudly and claim to put theirnrecommendations into effect, some of their more important resultsnmay occur through a process that is more akin to seepage thannto the clear making of intended changes. If some of the standardnjokes about the fate of committees have any truth in themmfornexample, that a unanimous report takes fifteen years to implementnand that thirty years will elapse before some of the proposals ofna divided committee take effectmthen final comments may be anlong time coming. The essays presented here can then be regardednas contributions to what may well be a continuing discussionh..n