Academic Cohorts: Benefits and Drawbacks of Being a Member of a Community of Learners.

Simon A. Lei, Denise Gorelick, Keily Short, Lauren Smallwood, Karen Wright-Porter

2011 · 62 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Introduction Cohort programs in higher education have become increasingly popular. A decline in student retention and graduation rates in the United Kingdom and the United States has been given as a major rationale for the development of cohort programs (Jarzablkowski, 2002). In order to address the need to improve student completion rates in higher education, colleges and universities are grouping students pursuing the same professional field into learning groups or cohort educational models (Unzueta et al., 2008). Academic cohorts have come about in response to the widespread perception that classroom teachers are isolated, and that their isolation reduces instructional effectiveness and prevents professionalism from fully developing in education (Hargreaves, 1994; Jarzabkowski, 2002; Seifert and Mandzuk, 2006). According to Hasinoffet al. (2003), in recent years, cohorts have become more common in teacher education as teacher educators continue to search for the optimal learning conditions in order to prepare student teachers for the teaching profession. Cohorts are defined as a group of about 10-25 students who begin a program of study together, proceed together through a series of developmental experiences in the context of that program of study, and end the program at approximately the same time (Barnett & Caffarella, 1992; Barnett et al., 2000; Maher, 2005). In essence, cohort education models stem from extensive research in social cognition which delineates that one learns best by interacting with others and sharing experiences (Wesson et al. 1996; John-Steiner & Maher, 2003). Additionally, the dynamics of group cohesion plays a major role in cohort education models' unity and support system (Unzueta et al., 2008). Group cohesion mirrors Vygotsky's second level of the zone of proximal development in that social interdependence encourages individual goal achievement (Unzueta et al., 2008). Characteristics of interdependence and group perception convey the concept that the group exists as one unit (Radin & Feld, 1985). Social group learning and group cohesion theories provide a framework for understanding cohort education models in the context of academic programs of study (Unzeuta et al., 2008). Cohort style of learning became popular in higher education institutions during the 1980's in response to pressure for reform of the educational system, with hopes to foster group interaction among adult learners (McCarthy et al., 2005). It is believed that the cohort education model fosters mutual intellectual and academic stimulation, facilitates the forming of social ties, and is easier for higher education institutions to organize and administer than traditional education programs (Seifert & Mandzuk, 2006). In this respect, cohorts prepare student teachers for their professional roles as teachers where their social networks will include social and professional relationships (Hasinoff et al., 2003). However, cohort programs can exhibit competitive discord and create unnecessary pressures among students. Most learning communities have three items in common: shared knowledge, shared knowing, and shared responsibility (McCarthy et al., 2005). A growing body of research and evidence suggests that learning communities can have a significant impact on student performance, attitudes, perceptions, and development (Buch & Spalding, 2008). This article provides an overview of the benefits and drawbacks of college cohort education models from the perspectives of cohort students and instructors who have taught cohort courses. Benefits of Cohort Membership There are a number of benefits of being a cohort member of the cohort program at the college level (Table 1). Cohort members and instructors recognize the importance of the culture that is created. McCarthy et al. (2005) have described culture as any group of people who associate with one another on the basis of some common purpose. …